The Kids Nobody Wanted on Their Scoreboard: How Superintendent Tom Bruce Built a School District Around the Ones Left Behind

Phillip Seager
Phillip Seager
November 18, 2026
7 min read
The Kids Nobody Wanted on Their Scoreboard: How Superintendent Tom Bruce Built a School District Around the Ones Left Behind

There is a quiet trick in education that makes a school look better overnight: remove the bottom 5 percent of students, and the scores rise. Tom Bruce knows it well. He also knows who ends up paying for it.

“There are a lot of those kids out there,” says Dr. Bruce, superintendent of Berrien Springs Public Schools in southwest Michigan. “No one was servicing them because they didn’t want those bad scores, those bad metrics.”

Berrien Springs decided to take them anyway.

A Small District With a Big Footprint

On a map, Berrien Springs looks like a rural Michigan district of about 2,000 students. It is more complicated than that. An international college in town brings families from around the world, and about 42 languages are spoken in the district. Generational farm families live alongside students who may be in town for only three years.

About 16 years ago, the district was in financial trouble. It was laying off staff, rehiring some, charging pay-to-play fees for sports, and even considering ending busing. Then-superintendent Jim Birmingham proposed a bold move: put the district’s last bit of reserve money into an alternative, largely online learning program for students the traditional model was failing.

The program has since grown to roughly 27 learning and tutoring centers across Michigan, including three in the Upper Peninsula, and about 5,000 students. Last school year it graduated about 1,400 of them, up from about 1,320 the year before.

Bruce is quick to credit the school board. “My school board, to their credit, said, hey, we’ll take those metrics. This is what’s right for kids.”

“This work definitely comes from the heart. It’s really easy to see when you attend one of our graduations. It is incredible.”

Those graduations often bring a dozen or more family members per graduate, many of whom are watching someone break a cycle in their family for the first time.

Where the Scoreboard Misleads

Bruce describes the students in the district’s alternative centers plainly. “They got pushed out, shoved out, dropped out, kicked out, whatever else out of a traditional school. A lot of them have adult problems as kids.” The average student arrives at 17.2 years old with only three credits. “They’ve already been harmed by the system.”

Because the state ranks schools on one scale, programs like his land near the bottom, and Bruce says that was never going to change. So the district is now pushing for a legislative fix. House Bill 6175 would keep the standard accountability system for traditional schools, but add an alternative academic performance rating and report card system for public schools already designated as alternative education by the State.   Parents could then better compare the best options in their area, because, as he puts it, “these students require more personalized experiences.” 

Bruce doesn’t dismiss accountability. He and his assistant superintendent, Steve Spenner,  are inspired by the book Extreme Ownership by by Jocko Willink and Leif Babin, and most of their leadership team are former athletes or coaches. The culture is high expectation, high accountability. The question he asks is what is being measured, and who is being served.

Building People - Not Rakes

Asked how faith shows up in his daily leadership, Bruce points to a men’s group he visited at his brother’s church in Arizona. They were studying James 2, which says that showing partiality to people because of how they look or act is a serious matter. The passage stayed with him.

“If we were building rakes, this would be easy,” he tells his team. “But here we’re developing fine young men and women.” That means working with their families too, in a small town where word travels fast. His goal is to design and develop a district where students, teachers, staff, and parents want to be.  "How do we create a place where people run to us?"

It also shapes how he handles the hardest part of leadership, which is staff who aren’t working out. His approach is to come alongside them with love and a genuine desire to help them improve. And if the fit still isn’t right, he hopes they leave saying, “They treated me with respect. They treated me well. We didn’t see eye to eye, but that’s a good organization.”

The Teacher Who Became “The Dog Teacher”

When asked for a decision where faith played a critical role, Bruce passes on budgets and building projects and tells a story about one person.

In a previous district, he supervised a fourth-grade teacher who consistently moved some of the toughest students forward. She was also harsh. Bruce came to believe she was teaching out of fear, keeping every child in front of her so she would feel safe. He prayed about it for a long time and set aside quiet retreat time, something he and a leadership group try to do four times a year, to get clarity.

Then he moved her to kindergarten. Colleagues thought he was crazy. “She will eat the children,” they told him. He told the teacher, who loves dogs, that she was now “the dog teacher,” free to fill her room with dog posters and stuffed animals. “These little guys (kindergartners), they want you to care for them and give them a hug a couple times a day.  Do that, and you will be their favorite!” She thrived! Bruce believes she taught another four or five years instead of burning out. He won’t take credit. “It wasn’t my idea. I can’t take credit for that one… I trust in you, Lord, and it’s going to work out.”

Hiring for Heart, Not Just Résumés or Titles

Bruce sees the district as more than a school system. It is a $100-million-plus organization with more than 700 employees, and every one of them has a family. So do the vendors, like a local architecture firm with about a dozen employees that depends heavily on the district’s work. As a younger man, he struggled to reconcile business success with Scripture, since the 1980s “greed is good” mindset never fit what he read in the Bible. Now he sees it differently. Good stewardship means providing for people, and their families...  Doing well means doing good for others.

That conviction recently shaped the district’s hiring. The staff and community created a “Profile of a Shamrock,” a picture of who they want on the team, built through surveys of staff, families, and students. Interviewers now put it in front of candidates. “This is who we are. We’re not apologizing for it. If you fit, this would be great. If you don’t, that’s okay.”

“I didn’t have God right there on the paper,” Bruce says, “but I’ll tell you what, he’s in the words and what we believe and how we’re running things.” The result was the district’s best hiring season yet, with new hires telling him, “I know I fit here.”

What We Can Take Into Monday

Bruce’s story offers a few practical lessons for any leader:

  • Ask who your metrics leave out. Look at who your numbers quietly exclude, and decide whether serving them is worth a worse-looking scoreboard.

  • Make room for retreat. Block out time with no phone or inbox so you can hear clearly on people decisions.

  • Put people in the right seat. Before you remove someone, ask whether a better fit exists.

  • Hire for values, not only credentials. Write down who you are, and show it to candidates.

  • Let your faith be visible. A Bible on a desk may tell people they will be treated with respect.

Bruce, who recently turned 60, says he wants to do more outside of work. He serves on a regional business development board, plays racquetball with a group of local men whose conversations often turn toward God, and tries to be intentional about his health. The center of his work, though, hasn’t changed: “Our work is bigger than schools, programs, or test scores. It's about providing hope so every student leaves us, Opportunity-Ready.”

James 2 warns against showing favoritism and makes clear that faith must be demonstrated through our actions. James 2:8 calls us to love our neighbor as ourselves, and verse 9 identifies favoritism as sin.  The question for each of us is the same one Berrien Springs faced: Can we claim to serve others while choosing which ones are worthy of a place on our scoreboard?

Share

Written by

Phillip Seager

Kingdom Factor Coach helping leaders integrate faith and business for lasting impact.

Interview with

Tom Bruce

Superintendent at Berrien Springs Public Schools

WANT TO SHARE YOUR STORY?

Join our community of faith-driven leaders and share how God is working in your business.

Get Started